What To Do

Categories

Social Bookmarks

Feeds

    • CommentAuthorFree Memberjsl9
    • CommentTimeAug 7th 2008
     
    jsl9

    I finished an 8K about 3 weeks ago and the next day had muscle pain in my right quad. I figured I pulled a muscle or two...I stopped running for a few days to rest, and the pain migrated towards my right knee. The pain is still there and doesn't seem to go away, no matter how much rest I get. :( I've been looking up Runner's knee, and the pain they describe seems to be what I have - discomfort in the patello-femoral joint. I've started to do some muscle strengthening exercises around that area, like lunges and squats. I figure it will strengthen the muscles near my knee and prevent more injury or am I wrong? Should I do these before a run? or throughout the day? I tried doing those exercises right before a run, and my muscles tensed up to the point I felt like my legs were immobile and I had to stop running and stretch my legs. I've heard about taking additives like Glucosamine or wearing a brace? I've been thinking about seeing a doctor, but not sure what kind of specialist would help examine my knee, any suggestions?...I've tried going to my primary care doctor, but he wasn't exactly an expert at it and wanted to do an mri on my knee which I think is kind of extreme. Anyway, would love to hear people's opinions...

    • CommentAuthorFree Memberyali
    • CommentTimeAug 13th 2008
     
    yali

    hi there,

    Runners knee can come from overtraining, increasing your mileage too hard too quickly, muscle imbalances etc.  I suffer from Runner's knee too due to some muscle imbalances...and squats are not what you should be doing now.  They can actually irritate the knee more.  Any 'squatting' like exercise can increase inflamation.  I go to a physiotherapist and they do some manual treatment for it, and have given me specific exercises and stretches.  They seem to help.  The physio has also suggested that I wear a flexible knee brace with an open patella hole for all my runs. It's not the most comfortable (but much more comfortable than knee pain!). 

    Good luck!

    • CommentAuthorFree Memberverysheri
    • CommentTimeAug 13th 2008
     
    verysheri

    I have been experiencing the same problem with my shorter, quicker runs (I'm training for the marine corps marathon). I spoke with my physical therapist about this a couple days ago, and he told me that this is mainly an issue of muscle weakness. He told me to AVOID squats and lunges - this irritates the knee a lot. One of the exercises he strongly recommended that I do (on off days, to strengthen the muscles) are single knee raises. Here are instructions on how to do them:

    "Lay on the floor, resting back on your hands. Have your legs straight out in front of you. Bend one knee and rest that foot on the floor. The other leg should still be straight. Lift your straight leg, keeping your knee straight. Raise your knee about 10 inches off the floor. Hold. Lower your leg and relax. Repeat."

     Other exercises to strengthen the muscles around your knee (mainly the quads) will help as well.

     Good luck!

  1.  
    giggles32006
    Well, I work in an orthopedics and sports medicine office...and I would say try to find a sports med doctor near you. Also...if the pain hasn't stopped by now even with rest...for sure go see a doctor. Most likely some stretches will help if its something like plica inflammation, but I wouldn't risk just writing it off as something minor until you know for sure....that's how people get into situations with torn ACLs and such!!!
    • CommentAuthorFree MemberGrantB
    • CommentTimeSep 8th 2008
     
    GrantB
    I have to agree with Giggles. I have had a history of knee problems when I was younger but no longer have them now. My problems stemmed from muscle strength imbalance in my legs (my hamstrings and vastus medialis, the quad muscle that looks like a teardrop on the inside nearest the knee, were weak.) Once those were strengthened up I learned that I had damaged my plica in my left knee. One operation later I was fine. One point worth mentioning, don't be afraid to ask about plica damage as it seems to get overlooked. I had been assessed by numerous doctors, specialists, and physiotherapists and all of them missed my plica damage until the surgeon went in and saw the problem with a scope. Maybe a good mri would solve that problem now (my injury was many moons ago) but you should still ask about it anyway.
    • CommentAuthorFree MemberGrantB
    • CommentTimeSep 8th 2008 edited
     
    GrantB
    ...Double post removed...
  2.  
    rpetreccajr
    What is the plica?
    • CommentAuthorFree MemberGrantB
    • CommentTimeSep 9th 2008
     
    GrantB
    You can look here for information on it. When I had my operation I was told that about 50% of the population have a plica. This site suggests more than that. http://www.athleticadvisor.com/Injuries/LE/Knee/plica_syndrome.htm
    • CommentAuthorFree Memberdanmccoy24
    • CommentTimeSep 30th 2008
     
    danmccoy24
    I just finished my first half-marathon two days ago, and I've experienced the same knee pain.  It hurts enough that I can't tell if it is injury or just running pain.  I put an ice pack on my knee for 20 minutes immediately following my cool down stretch, and it has REALLY helped.  The pain was normally most severe a couple hours after a run, but the ice pack seemed to help.  A doc told me ice pack for twenty minutes, follow that with a heated compression after every run and the pain will lessen, if not subside.
  3.  
    rpetreccajr
    If you have passed the acute phase of an injury where heat is a bad thing (increases inflamation), then it has been my experience that alternating icing and heating will help you heal faster. Ice cuts down on the inflamation and then heat increases circulation. I've been told and tried 20 minutes ice followed by 20 minutes of heat for as many cycles as I had time and patience to do. If you just did the half-marathon two days ago, you might want to try just ice for a few more days and just rest.
  4.  
    aussiebloke
    I am a physiotherapist - my suggestion - as per many before me is to avoid lunges and squats - these exercises, whilst good quad strengthening exercises also serve to compress the patello femoral joint and potentially cause further joint damage. The problem is likely related to either a patello femoral joint issue related to a muslce imbalance  - tight ITB and weak VMO (medial quads) or a patella tendinopathy. My suggestion would be to get some strapping tape and use 6-8 pieces 4-5 inches in length. Start at the top of your patella on the outside of the knee. Pull the tape across thus moving your patella more medially. Repeat this with the 6-8 pieces moving from the top of your patella to the bottom. Try a short run/walk and see if it helps. If not go see a DR/PT
  5.  
    MassageGuy

    and don't forget shoes...

    I had hideous issues with the same knee thing, I thought I was doing everything right - had the expensive running shoes ... stretched etc, and yet this paid continued to come back.

    I went to a shoe shop that specialises in fitting running shoes,not with some generic foot testing software, all camera based etc (active feet for those who live in Melbourne Australia)

    Found that I pronated more than I thought I did, they fitted me out with a different brand of shoe, and while I had to be considerate for a week or so, I am pain free, and 500kms later I am about to attempt my first marathon.

    Sometimes this is overlooked simply because we figure that really expensive footwear means it's the RIGHT footwear, absolutely not the case.

    Thats my 2 cents... hope it helps

  6.  
    runlikeagirl1982

    I dealt with this problem when i started marathon training...it was an over-training issue and my quads weren't strong enough, so there was an imbalance with my quads and hams.  I did strength training in my quads and avoided downhill running.  I also used a knee strap for 'runner's knee' or chondramalacia.  You can get these at Walgreen's it fits right underneath your knee cap and holds it in place while you're running to relieve pain. It won't relieve it 100% but enough to get through your run.  It'll eventually pass, you just have to baby it...maybe change surfaces for a little while and run on grass or dirt.  And always ice after your runs.

    • CommentAuthorFree Memberjakeg
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2008
     
    jakeg

    I've had problems with runner's knee my entire life (since high school anyway), and these are the things that have helped me the most:

     - stretching hamstrings, quads, and espcially the ITB thoroughly after every run.  a foam roller helps a lot with the ITB as well.

    - modifying my gait/biomechanics to ease pressure on my knees. my preferred method is through ChiRunning, but you may be able to find a local sports therapist who specializes in gait retraining.

    - strengthening my quads, hips, glutes, and core muscles.  like everyone above has said, avoid squats and lunges (they made it worse for me).  my preferred methods are yoga and pilates, which will work muscles in your legs you never knew you had (or needed), and improve your alignment and balance.

    - ice baths after long runs.  a little uncomfortable at first, but after a long hard run it can actually be quite a relief, and i find it much more useful than an ice pack.

     

  7.  
    gallegosrun

    What I'm doing, with less than a month before my first marathon:

     First, my ITB issues just started and weren't terrible. I took 8 days off, icing, NSAIDs, replaced my running shoes with a fresh pair. Then did a 4 mile run and it was there, but far less and didn't worsen. Still, I wasn't happy. Then, after tons of reading here and elsewhere, identified it as textbook ITB.

    Since then, started doing ITB stretches multiple times a day (hadn't ever learned the importance of ever doing them, so I guess I shouldn't be surprised I have this issue now), continued NSAID treatment, topical Arnica. I also got a gym membership for one month.

    Stationary bike (recline and standard) don't bother at all, so I'm doing longish workouts on that trying to get my heart rate up to about what it is while running. After a couple days of that I tried 2.5 miles on the treadmill and the pain was even further reduced.

     So, what I'm going to try is to continue this, try to increase my mileage on the treadmill only (flat non-crowned, absorbent surface) while biking--the extra warm-up on the bike first seems to help. This was supposed to be taper month anyway, but I'm going to try to work up to some mid-distance runs before the race. I'm trying to schedule my NSAIDs so that I workout right before the next dose is needed, as I don't want them to simply mask pain that might be there.  I'll look up some suggested knee wraps to try also.

    If I can get through the rest of this training without bad flare up, I'm going to attempt my race. I have serious doubts that I'll attempt another full marathon after this one (waayy more time needed than I bargained for), sticking to halfs probably. Then again, 2 years ago I never thought I'd attempt my first marathon.